Having re-watched it this last weekend, I’m pretty sure So I Married an Axe Murderer is one of the most underrated romantic comedies of the nineties. What I really want to say here is SIMAM is the underrated romantic comedy, which would imply that it is impossible under normal circumstances to underrate a romantic comedy, a film genre I loathe. But that would be hyperbole, and we’re all about the reasoned discourse here at Anvil and Sprocket.
It’s light fare to be sure (romantic comedy) and the plot falls apart if you look at it a sideways (romantic comedy), but Mike Meyers’ Stuart MacKenzie, the aging scottish LaRouchie, is funny enough to make you shoot haggis out your nose. SIMAM eschews the meet-cute for an unusual first date, as Charlie (also Meyers) helps Harriet (Nancy Travis)out in her busy butcher shop. Under director Thomas Schlamme, the movie flirts briefly with cloying, but cloying never even makes to to first base.
Unlike most romantic comedies, So I Married an Axe Murderer at no point glorifies stalking.
There are lots of great skit-like moments in the film as well. Phil Hartman is a barely stable Alcatraz tour guide (“My name is John Johnson but everyone here calls me Vicki”) and Alan Arkin is a sensitive, soft-spoken police chief. Steven Wright and Michael Richards have less memorable cameos, but Tony- and Emmy-winning Ammanda Plummer is excellent as Harriet’s slightly creepy sister Rose.
Considering it’s available new in the bargain rack at many places for under $10, it’s hard not to call this one a keeper.